Judicial Procedure in Ancient Gaelic Court Part 1 (Civil Court)
by Liathame DunBar
Step One: Aidbriud (assertion)
* The Plaintiff (victim or kin of victim) would contract with an
advocate to publicly imply the wrongdoing of another against the plaintiff.
(it is apparent to represent oneself was thought unwise)
Step Two: Path of Pursuit
* The Plaintiffs advocate must choose one of the five paths along
which to plead his case. They are:
1. Fir – Truth (cases involving property , allegiance or perjury)
2. Dliged – Entitlement (enforces contractual rights)
3. Cert – Justice (to balance unfair contracts)
4. Téchtae – Propriety (affects servile dependence or very old
issues)
5. Coirn-athchomairc – Proper Inquiry (a catch all when none of
the above apply)
* Note: If an advocate chooses the wrong path or changes paths during
pleading he would be fined the value of one milk cow.
Step Three: Árach (Pledges and Sureties)
* The Plaintiff would offer a pledge or surety dependent on which path
the case is being pursued to indicate their commitment to the proceedings
and the impending judgement. The proper pledges are:>
1. Fir – firgille or truth pledge valued at one milk cow (smacht)
2. Dliged – naidm or enforcing surety by binding. Valued at the
principals Honour Price
3. Cert – smachtgille or penalty pledge. Valued at 1/7th of one
milk cow.
4. Téchtae – rath or paying surety. rath surety is like bail
value is determined by the case involved. If a principal defaults the
amount of the rath is distrained from him.
5. Coirn-athchomairc – aitire or hostage surety. When an
individual places him/herself between two parties as surety. If the
principal defaults, the one who has placed themselves as surety willingly
goes into bondage until the debt is settled or they are ransomed at the
body price of a freeman, seven cumals or twenty-one milk cows.
* An equal pledge or surety would be expected from the defendant. Once
this is done and assuming neither party defaults, the case may proceed.
Step Four : Tacrae (Pleading)
* Each advocate pleads his case according to the path the Plaintiffs
advocate chose. Evidence is given and witnesses are called to testify.
Step Five: Frecrae (Counter Pleading)
* Each advocate rebuts his counterparts pleading. Witnesses may be
cross-examined.
Step Six: Breth (Judgement)
* After considering the testimony and evidence the Judges are required
to consult any dignitaries that may be present. The judges formulate the
actual judgement and they must support it by stating the source of
confirmation.
1. Roscad or Legal Verse
2. Fásach Maxim or Triad
3. Cosmailius or Analogy
4. Aicned Natural Law
* If a judge mistakenly states the wrong type of resource he is fined
for a false judgement gúbreth
Step Seven: Forus (Announcement)
* Public announcement of the judgement and the foundation of said
judgement (forus)
Step Eight: Forbae (Conclusion)
* Distraint must begin within three days or be forfeit
Sources:
1. A Guide to Early Irish Law, Fergus Kelly, Dundalgan Press Ltd., ISBN
0790-4657 & 0-901282-95-2
2. Foundations of Modern Law, Dale McKenny
3. Britannica Online
prepared by Liathame DunBar
©1998 Clannada na Gadelica, all rights reserved.
|